|Home » Forums » Cabinet and Millwork Installation » Message||Login|
You are not logged in. Consider these WOODWEB Member advantages:
Coping saw teeth direction3/11
As many years as I've been at this, it never occured to me on which way the teeth should be pointing (toward the handle or away and what the difference is. Is one way better than the other? Does direction or the amount of teeth make a difference depending upon what species od crown or base im coping?
I feel like such an amature asking, but then again, no one knows everything about this trade, even though there are plenty of know it alls. :-)
Away from the handle. Fine tooth for hardwoods and medium for softwoods.
It is whatever you choose. Whatever works best for you.
away for control and good clean cut on face
The normal way for teeth to be set in one man handsaws in Europe and the US is so the saw cuts om the push stroke. The Japanese saws cut on the pull stroke, and can have a much thinner blade as a result. They also pull their handplanes, by the way.
Your coping saw can be set up either way, your preference.
The old Champion tooth two man logging saws have a tooth pattern that cuts both ways for better efficiency.
And there is the old story about the Shaker woman that watched a water powered sash saw that sawed on the down stroke only (mimicing a pit saw), realized it as 50% wasted effort, and came up the idea of putting saw teeth on a wheel and rotating it. The English have their version of the story, omitting the Shaker woman.
Thanks all, that definately helps
Using a coping saw on the push cut is for the folks that must always mount the toilet paper rolling out from behind.
It is a thin blade, held in a light steel bow. Aggressive accurate cutting is most possible with a pull cut. This is the traditional use of this tool.
I came up through the ranks, at 63 years old I've seen about all you can see in this business. I was taught by a German journeyman, have attended countless guild meetings, visited probably a couple hundred different shops through my career, attended a gazillion seminars, trade shows, conventions, local shows, etc. Worked in this field since I was 12 years old and have owned my own business for almost forty years.
That being said - I just have to agree with joiner. Hand coping saws were designed for a pull stroke. Period. Sure you can flip it around - but ask any seasoned wood shop veteran which direction gives you the most power and control and I'm sure they'll all agree - teeth towards the handle - pull stroke wins every time.
Don't fool with history. There's a reason they've done it this way for over a 100 years.
That's my story and I'm sticking to it. If you don't agree - I'm not going to be tempted into a dispute here. Just saying it like it is. :-) And yes - I'm all for individualism, if it works for you - go for it. But the rule still stands for the masses.
Dang young whippersnappers... And I say this all with a smile!
I you are cutting drown and you have the blade on the saw with the teeth toward your hand and you use a pull stroke, how do you see the line to cut, wouldn't it be on the back side of the wood??
Misspelled "crown". If you are cutting CROWN, Sorry
Somebody post a video cause I don't follow how to use a pull stroke to cope crown mould.
I've got roughly the same training and experience as ML and-
The teeth point to the handle, the saw cuts on the pull stroke; cutting on the push stroke is like pushing string.
If I can figure out how to use my newly purchased video camera, I will post a demo of it- it's been hotly debated on several forums.
Oh, and it's way faster too.
If you think about it for a minute you will conclude the teeth should point toward the handle. The other way around causes the thin frame to flex making for a limp blade. Pull cutting utilizes the blade in tension, doesn't act like a hot noodle that way.
A question for the guys who use their coping saws on the pull stroke:
I have never used a coping saw for coping crown - never have put up crown. I have used it for cutting all sorts of things - inlays, repair, details and pierced work.
I gave my two cents expecting worse reaction. Yes, when using the saw on the pull, I did the crown from below, and it ain't fun.
In response to Rick-
It's just 2 pieces of stock screwed together at 90 deg. with a cleat tacked to the inside bottom. It holds sprung molding at the same angle as it will be when hung, makes it easier to get a square cut when coping.
Wow, this was a shocker to read.
I guess I have to say that it of course seems like it would work but as long as I have ever been around any type of harp style saw its a pull cut always. I honestly dont see how you could NOT have it cut on the pull stroke as every time you bear down on the blade your taking away your tension if you flip the blade? The harp of the coping saw is not very stout. I have had a blade catch on the push side of a pull stroke and have the blade pop right out.
Was kinda shocked to read all the push stroke and "however you want" replies. Thats a new one to me.
I cope crown daily with a pull stroke and have never had the first issue.
Oh well, whatever floats your boat I guess.
Just saw the video request. You can just google or youtube coping crown and there are oodles of videos out there coping just as Ive seen it done (and I do it). Face up, pull stroke, I dont see the rub.