Long-Span Shelves

Home » Knowledge Base » Knowledge Base Article





	Today's Sponsors: High Point Grinding - Total Saw Solutions Historical Plus Wood Hoffmann Machine Company Holz Her U.S. Inc. Howard S. Twichell Co. HSD USA Hvalsoe Sawmill Ltd. ICA North America Icy Straits Lumber IDM Impact Search and Placement Industrial Air Solutions Industrial Maid Integra Tooling InTrading Invicta Woodworking Machines IpeDepot.com irsauctions.com Italpresse J&P Machines J. Gibson McIlvain Company JIT Hardware Supplies, Inc. JMHsoftware.com John G. Weber Co. Joos USA Inc. KCDw Kerber Farms and Mill Keystone Wood Specialties Keytrix Data Systems Kiln-direct.com Kleiberit Adhesives USA, Inc. Koch Machinery and Systems Komo Machine, Inc. Kreg Tool Company Kremlin Lacy Cypress Inc. Laguna Tools Lane Stanton Vance LEUCO Tool Corporation Lewis Lumber Products Lobo Machinery Corp. Loch Logging and Lumber Logosol Lubie Lube Lumber Resources MACHINEKING.com Machines Italia - Italian Trade Commission Macoser, Inc. Mahros Maine Woods Company Mann and Parker Lumber Co. MARTIN Woodworking Machines Corp. Mastercam - CNC Software Matthews Mill Maya Positioning Equipment Mereen-Johnson Machine Company Merritt Woodwork Microvellum Mid America Protective Coatings Mid-America Hardwoods Middle Valley Lumber Midwest Automation Midwest Sandright Mikron Woodworking Machinery Mill Outlet Minimax Mirror Reflections Mississippi Heart Pine Miter Clamp MLS Machinery USA, Inc. MLS Machinery Modern Woodworking Magazine Moldingknives.com Monarch Machinery Morbidelli Moulder Services Moulder Techniques Mountainside Wood Products Multicam, Inc. NAP Gladu NCME Hardware Resources Hardwood Council Hardwood Store of N.C. Inc. Hasko Machines Heidelberg Flooring Hendrick Her-Saf Hermance Machine Company

WOODWEB DISCLAIMS any and all RESPONSIBILITY and LIABILITY for the accuracy and application of the information below. Readers agree to evaluate the significance and limitations of the information provided, and accept full responsibility for the application of this information. Read More ...

Would you like to add information to this article?
Interested in writing or submitting an article?
Have a question about this article?

Long-Span Shelves

Ideas and resources for dealing with long shelf spans. December 30, 2005

Question
My client is looking for free-span paint grade library shelves greater than 40" wide x 11" deep. My options are wide open for material choice, but a center stile and/or partition are out. I can't tolerate any sagging, so I'd love to tap into your experience on how to make long spans that are sag resistant.

Forum Responses
(Cabinetmaking Forum)
From contributor A:
I'd do 6/4 soft maple, planed down to 1-1/4" final thickness. You could store your encyclopedia collection on a shelf
like this with no discernable deflection. Make sure you price accordingly. Spans over about 44" should be a torsion box construction.

From contributor B:
I've used white oak with a 5' span, 1" thick with no sag.

From contributor C:
If you are going paint grade, look at 5/4 Soft Maple for solid wood shelves.

From contributor D:
Hickory is the strongest wood I've run across. Use grain filler and you�re ready to paint.

From contributor E:
Try this link:
Sagulator

From Gene Wengert, technical advisor Sawing and Drying Forum:
Check CABINET MAKER magazine, August 2005, for a good bit of information about shelf design, including effect of species (denser is better), thickness and so on. Solid wood is much better than composites.

From contributor F:
For that span I have used 1-3/8" solid core birch doors - rip and edge � it�s quick and easy. I just finished a shelf unit with 12" x 60" fixed shelves. I used two 3/4" plywood rips, let in 1" steel c channel between layers at front edge. There was no sag and no problem. I have had problems with solid wood shelving cupping and or twisting over time. Laminating two pieces helps with this problem.

From contributor G:
To contributor A: What is torsion box construction??

From contributor H:
Try to get past issue of Better Homes and Gardens, WOOD, March 2004 issue 154. This is the best information I have seen regarding this question.

From the original questioner:
These are all great ideas, and the online resources are all good. I especially liked the Sagulator- even if the specific material you're looking at isn't listed, you can get a good sense for the relative impact on shelf sag by changing one parameter at a time (width, depth, etc.) and seeing the effect it has on sag.

Have you reviewed the related Knowledge Base areas below?

KnowledgeBase: Knowledge Base

KnowledgeBase: Cabinetmaking